Englishmen frenchmen spaniards an essay in comparative psychology

Life[ edit ] De Madariaga graduated with a degree in engineering in Paris, France. He then went to work as an engineer for the Northern Spanish Railway Company but abandoned this work to return to London and become a journalist, writing in English, for The Times.

Englishmen frenchmen spaniards an essay in comparative psychology

The word "socialism" often implies two quite different phenomena: A doctrine and an appeal based on it, a program for changing life, and A social structure that exists in time and space.

The most obvious examples include Marxism as contained in the "classic" writings of Marx and others and the social structure that exists in the U. Among the fundamental principles of the state doctrine in these countries is the assertion that the connection between the two phenomena is very simple.

On the one hand, it is asserted, there is a scientific theory which proves that after achieving a definite level in the development of productive forces, mankind will pass over to a new historic formation; this theory points the way to the most rational paths for such a transition.

Englishmen frenchmen spaniards an essay in comparative psychology

And on the other hand, we are assured, there is the embodiment of this scientific prognosis, its confirmation. As an example of quite a different point of view we cite H.

Wells, who visited Russia in and, though infected by the worship of socialism, fashionable then as now, nevertheless almost instinctively refused to accept Marxism, in this sense reflecting the antipathy toward all scholastic theories typical of an Englishman. In his book Russia in the Shadows, Wells writes: The state system established as a result is therefore defined and shaped by the necessity of holding power.

Since these tasks are entirely different, the official theory and the actual implementation have nothing in common.

The Socialist Phenomenon by Igor Shafarevich

It would be incautious to take either of these assertions on faith. On the contrary, it would be desirable, first, to study both "socialisms" independently, without any a priori hypotheses, and only then attempt to come to conclusions about the connections that exist between them.

We shall begin with socialism understood as a doctrine, as an appeal. All such doctrines and as we shall see, there were many of them have a common core--they are based on the complete rejection of the existing social structure.

They call for its destruction and paint a picture of a more just and happy society in which the solution to all the fundamental problems of the times would be found. Furthermore, they propose concrete ways of achieving this goal.

In religious literature such a system of views is referred to as belief in the thousand-year Kingdom of God on earth--chiliasm. Borrowing this terminology, we shall designate the socialist doctrines of this type as "chiliastic socialism. In doing so, we shall attempt to extract a picture of the future society envisaged, leaving to one side for the moment the motivation as well as the concrete means recommended for achieving the ideal.

The first example takes us to Athens in B. Here he depicts a teaching fashionable in the Athens of the time. The plot is as follows: The women of the city, wearing beards and dressed in men's clothing, come to the assembly and by a majority vote pass a resolution transferring all power in the state to women.

They use this power to introduce a series of measures, which are expounded in a dialogue between Praxagora, the leader of the women, and her husband, Blepyros.

Find a copy in the library

Here are several quotations. Compulsory Universal Community Property is what I propose to propose; across-the-board Economic Equality, to fill those fissures that scar our society's face.

No more the division between Rich and Poor. We'll wear the same clothes, and share the same food. My initial move will be to communalize land, and money, and all other property, personal and real.

But take the landless man who's invisibly wealthy He'll deposit it all in the Fund. I'll knock out walls and remodel the City into one big happy household, where all can come and go as they choose. I'm pooling the women, creating a public hoard for the use of every man who wishes to take them to bed and make babies.

A system like this requires a pretty wise father to know his own children.Add tags for "Englishmen, Frenchmen, Spaniards: an essay in comparative psychology".

Be the first. Get this from a library!

Find out more about studying History BA Hons (V) at Lancaster University. Englishmen, Frenchmen, Spaniards;: An essay in comparative psychology [Salvador de Madariaga] on urbanagricultureinitiative.com *FREE* shipping on qualifying urbanagricultureinitiative.com: Salvador de Madariaga. Get this from a library! Englishmen, Frenchmen, Spaniards; an essay in comparative psychology. [Salvador de Madariaga].

Englishmen, Frenchmen, Spaniards; an essay in comparative psychology. [Salvador de Madariaga]. Aims & methods of a chair of Spanish studies; an inaugural lecture delivered before the University of Oxford on 15 May / By: Madariaga, Salvador de, Published: () Englishmen, .

[The following is a transcription of Igor Shafarevich's The Socialist urbanagricultureinitiative.com work was originally published in Russian in France under the title Sotsializm kak iavlenie mirovoi istorii in.

Find out more about studying History BA Hons (V) at Lancaster University. Englishmen, Frenchmen, Spaniards;: An essay in comparative psychology [Salvador de Madariaga] on urbanagricultureinitiative.com *FREE* shipping on qualifying urbanagricultureinitiative.com: Salvador de Madariaga.

Englishmen, Frenchmen, Spaniards; an essay in comparative psychology (Book, ) [urbanagricultureinitiative.com]